|
TranscRipt
|
|
|
|
Here you can read through
the whole transcript for this interview. Click on the listen icon to hear any of the tracks.
You can search on this transcript by clicking
[here]
for the research tool. Alternatively you can
download the full transcript [here]
Peter | | Person with diabetesBorn in Sheffield in 1942. Diagnosed Type 1 in Sheffield in 1954
Overview: Peter`s father was a professor and both parents were well-informed about diabetes after his older brother was diagnosed in 1945. They spotted Peter`s symptoms early and at first he only needed four units of Lente insulin to last 24 hours. He was educated at Oxford and worked in the steel industry for several years. He is now a management consultant and has few problems associated with diabetes. He has recently remarried, after being widowed in 2003, and has a daughter with diabetes who is `much more able to cope with disturbances to her daily routine than I am`. | [View Full Interview] |
| Transcript... |
|
| (1) Tell me aboutyour backgorund
| (1)
Tell me about your background.
I‘m sixty two. I‘ve lived in
Sheffield - I was born in Sheffield - and lived here
for most of my young life. My father was first a lecturer and later a professor
at the university. My mother never had a salaried job after she married.
She didn‘t have a national insurance number until well after her sixty-fifth
birthday, when the tax authorities gave her two at once, which was a bit difficult
for her. I was educated at a grammar school in Sheffield, and was lucky enough
to win a place at Oxford and read a degree there at the beginning of the sixties. I
worked for the steel industry in Sheffield for nine or ten years, then moved
away from Sheffield, with my wife, down to the Cotswolds, and worked in a number
of short term jobs, and then eventually settled in a job in management consultancy,
which is how I earn my living to this day.
Are your childhood memories those
of being quite well off?
Yes, comfortably off. My father
was a university professor from the year I was eight onwards, and achieved
fairly senior position in the university, being pro-vice chancellor for a
time, and being asked in his fifties to take on the wardenship of one of the
largest halls of residence, when the university decided that it was important
that the halls should have wardens who were senior members of the university
rather than junior. We lived a comfortable life. My parents had a car, though
my mother didn‘t - although she learnt to drive in her fifties - never had
a car of her own, and would simply use the family car, and drop my father
at his office in the university before using the car for the day.
Did you have any brothers and
sisters?
Yes. My mother conceived four
times in total, and I would have been the third child. I had one elder brother,
who survived, who was five years older than me. Another brother between us
died in an accident when he was less than two years old. Then I was born,
and finally my mother gave birth to a stillborn daughter a year or two after
I was born. My older brother was diagnosed as diabetic when he was eight,
roughly at the end of the war in 1945. We were living in Epsom then - my
father had been appointed to a job in London for five years. And my parents found themselves being put on
the books of Dr RD Lawrence, who was one of the great diabetic treatment specialists
at that time. He was one of the founders of the British Diabetic Association,
along with HG Wells and one or two other people, and played an important part
in the development of Diabetes UK,
and is, you know, a great name. I think my own... the diagnosis of me as
diabetic was made much easier for my parents, because they already had a diabetic
son. And by the time I developed diabetes, he was - let me think - he was
sixteen and had been diabetic for half his life. They found it very easy
to spot the symptoms very early, and they found a lot of the problems that
people have with getting used to the idea of having a diabetic child on insulin,
they found a lot of these much easier to deal with, because they‘d got so
much experience of it already.
|
| | (2)
And what did your parents learn from RD Lawrence?
I think Lawrence was, in many ways, well ahead of his time,
which was one of the secrets of his success. Quite a lot of the things they
learnt from Lawrence were things that probably didn‘t really
get formulated as part of the theory of how to cope with diabetes until some
time later. Most of all, they learnt early on that a diabetic really cannot
leave it to professional experts to control his diabetes for him. The diabetic
has to know how to run his own life from hour to hour and day to day, and
the role of the specialist is to provide the specialist knowledge, and the
diagnostic tests that are necessary, in the context of the diabetic using
his own head most of all. I‘ve always thought of it as being rather like…
the process of trying to achieve the balance between food and exercise and
insulin is not unlike the possible ways of controlling a space shot to the
moon. You could, if you‘d like to, arrange to use the latest possible technology
to work out exactly what engines should be used and how they should be fired,
and shoot the thing at the moon and knowing that you will get there. But
it‘s much better to shoot the thing off in a general way aiming at the moon,
and then to be in a position to do mid-course corrections when you want to.
And diabetes is all about the mid-course corrections. It‘s not about the
very carefully calculated firing procedures, which get you all the way to
the moon without needing to touch the tiller. And Lawrence
was very clear indeed that the only hope for a diabetic was to be in charge
of his own life. And this made a lot of the things that I was taught to do
by my parents from an early age - things that they were quite clear were important,
because Lawrence made it clear that they were important - I think I was very
fortunate to have that grounding. And looking back - it‘s difficult, because
early interactions with the diabetic specialist every few months as a boy,
I wasn‘t perhaps listening as carefully as I should have done to everything
the doctor said to my mother, while I sat there and fidgeted - but I got a
feeling that my parents felt, at the end of my teens, that they had learnt
more from Lawrence in the first place, and that they‘d learnt rather less
from the diabetic specialist in whose care I was put. I was actually diagnosed
as diabetic on my mother‘s birthday in 1954, about two months before my twelfth
birthday. And a sign of how early the diagnosis was can be gathered from
the fact that my first dose of insulin, to last me twenty four hours, was
four units of Lente insulin, which was the latest sort of insulin then invented.
Over the next two years, my need for insulin rose steadily and fast, as my
pancreas obviously gave up producing its own insulin - not in a sudden way,
but over a period of probably a couple of years - which is an interesting
insight, really. The idea that diabetes is something that you only notice
when it‘s already quite serious definitely didn‘t apply in my case. The other
interesting thing about my case is that, like an awful lot of diabetics, the
diagnosis that my insulin production was beginning to suffer was made a few
weeks after I‘d had a week off school with some sort of ‘flu-like illness.
Not part of an epidemic, but simply being at home in bed with a high temperature,
and this appears to be a common part of the experience for a lot of diabetics
when they first develop it as children. If it were possible to vaccinate
against that particular virus, it would certainly be worth doing, I think.
|
| | (3)
Was the diagnosis made by a GP or by a hospital?
No, the initial guess was my
parents, who were fairly confident. They went to the GP, who was a fairly
close friend of theirs, and she immediately referred them to the senior diabetic
specialist in, what was then, a hospital in central Sheffield.
I was admitted to hospital for diagnostic tests, and a glucose tolerance test
indicated that I certainly was developing diabetic symptoms, or was developing
diabetes, and the first injection of insulin followed. I was put in a large
ward of three dozen people, and perhaps - you were asking about my parents‘
prosperity - my parents were in a position to be able to afford to pay for
a private room for me; a side ward at the end of the main ward. I was there
for nearly a fortnight, I think - not sure why it would take so long, but
it did. And for most of that fortnight made everyone‘s life an absolute misery,
by racing round the ward in a wheelchair, which was not being used by anyone
else, and generally being tied down as far as possible by the nurses, who
gave me all sorts of tasks to carry out, simply because it was the best way
of keeping me entertained. I served tea and coffee to every patient in bed.
No nurse had to go and fetch a bottle or a bedpan at any point in my fortnight.
And I was sent to bed early at the end of each day, usually fairly tired out.
The only other thing I can remember, at that point, is being required to cycle
a certain distance every day on a cycling machine in the basement of the hospital,
and seeing a film called On Moonlight Bay with Doris Day in it, which I‘m
sure was completely unsuitable for a boy of eleven and three quarters, but
it was the only film on offer that particular Saturday evening.
So, this was not a children‘s
ward?
No, it wasn‘t. I don‘t know
- I was discussing this with my wife the other day - I don‘t know why, but
my parents already realised enough that it was more important to have me in
the care of somebody who understood diabetes than to have me in the children‘s
hospital. And I don‘t think the children‘s hospital started getting any hand
in the treating of young diabetics in Sheffield until some years after I was diagnosed. I was expected to
be able to cope in an adult hospital, and definitely required to cope without
making too much noise or causing too much trouble. Looking back, over the
years, I think I managed to grow up just fast enough to avoid getting thrown
out of the hospital for childish behaviour, but it was a close run thing,
|
| | (4)
sometimes, in the early years.
Apart from having to do this
cycling every day, can you remember what other training you got?
I think probably the notion that
training was something that was anybody‘s responsibility rather fell apart
- didn‘t really exist then. It was very much more a case of nurses being
required to share their knowledge with the patients as far as possible, and
the doctors obviously doing likewise. And it was made very much easier for
both parties by my parents‘ ability to give the impression they understood
what was going on, without giving the impression they were cocky about it.
And I think that meant that, on the whole, the doctors and the nurses both
felt that they didn‘t have to worry too much - they could leave my parents
to sort out how I was going to live my life. I remember being absolutely
terrified when, at the end of this fortnight, I - and after a fortnight on
insulin, pretty well - I went home, and my mother said "right, yes, you‘re
going back to school on Monday", and "we‘ve arranged this and this
about coping with your diabetic diet - not giving you sweet puddings for lunch",
and "you‘ll be okay". And I thought to myself "I do hope I
am okay. How on earth am I going to manage?". And I found that, in
fact, I was okay, and that particular hurdle was got over without too much
difficulty. But certainly, at the end of that first fortnight, I was very
well aware that there were an awful lot of things that I didn‘t fully understand.
I didn‘t know all the things I needed to know in order to obey the rules about
diet, which were much more tightly formulated then than they are now. I was
absolutely terrified, until I found out that I could actually cope with the
life I had been leading, modified suitably.
|
| | (5)
Who taught you to do injections - a nurse or your parents?
I‘m sorry to say I can‘t remember.
It‘s so long ago that I have... but effectively, it‘s bound to have been a
nurse, because my parents wouldn‘t normally have come to visit me in hospital
that early in the day. At that time, I was having one injection a day, immediately
before my breakfast, and so I can assume it must have been staff nurse Bush.
I shall always remember staff nurse Bush. She was fairly bow-legged for a
girl in her twenties in the 1950s. She obviously had been very badly nourished
as a child or something. She was very self-conscious abut her bow-legs, but
she was a lovely lady, and I learnt a lot from her, I think. I don‘t remember
it being terribly difficult to learn how to do injections. The sight of my
brother doing it for the previous eight years had been enough to give me the
idea that it was something one could learn to do, and given that I was going
to learn to do it, I got on and learnt it. But maybe that‘s just me rewriting
history for myself - it would be difficult to feel bad about it, I guess.
What were the syringes like?
What were the...?
Syringes like?
They were nice hygienic pieces
of equipment. They ought to be - they were kept in proper surgical spirit,
in a metal container that was typically six inches long and over half an inch
in diameter, and unscrewed and screwed up when you wanted to take the lid
off, so that the spirit wouldn‘t leak out. The main syringe was glass with
stainless steel fittings and a stainless steel needle, and the finest needle
you could get in the National Health Service, at the time, was a seventeen
gauge. The current disposable needles are twenty six gauge, and I can‘t remember
what these are in millimetres, but the bigger the gauge number, the finer
the diameter of the needle concerned. The story was of tube makers, in those
days, claiming to make the world‘s finest tube, and then the competitor would
put another tube inside it and send it back. And I‘m sure you could get a
modern hypodermic disposable needle - twenty six gauge needle - I‘m sure you
could get it through the centre of a seventeen gauge needle. I have suffered,
over the years, from quite a lot of fat atrophy. When I first developed diabetes,
I used my legs for injections. I did my best to move up and down the leg
every day, but the fat got eaten away quite heavily, and you can still see
sort of gaps in the fat on my thighs. Two factors in this: one, I‘m sure,
is the diameter of the needles I was using, and the other, of course, is that
at that stage I was using insulin made from the pancreases of cows. Virtually
every cow that was slaughtered in Britain,
at that time, had its pancreas removed and frozen and sent to an insulin manufacturer
for processing. And cow‘s insulin had tremendous local reactions at the point
of injection, which is one of the main reasons why pig‘s insulin was such
an improvement, when it arrived from Denmark
a few years after I started. The syringes, as I say, were large. They also
were expected to last for a very long time. I should doubt very much whether
I used more than half a dozen syringes in the first seven or eight years of
my diabetic life.
|
| | (6)
What were you taught in hospital about testing sugar levels?
I‘m glad to say I developed diabetes
after the introduction of Clinitest tablets. When my brother had first developed
diabetes, my parents had been required to instruct him in using Benedict‘s
solution to test for sugar, and shall always remember my father using a test-tube,
which he would heat on the hot plate of the cooker with the relevant mixture
of urine and water and Benedict‘s solution, and standing there and watching
it go one colour or another. And if he left it on the cooker a little too
long, the solution would boil too strongly and some would leap out onto the
rest of the cooker. My mother would go absolutely spare. By the time all
this had... By the time I developed diabetes, all this had rather disappeared,
because it was... the Clinitest system was available instead. You took out
this nice little kit. You stood the test-tube up in the lid, so that it wasn‘t
going to fall over. You put into it five drops of urine and ten drops of
water - I think it was that, perhaps it was ten of urine and five of water,
I can‘t remember now - then you opened the Clinitest bottle, took out one
tablet, making sure you didn‘t do more than sort of keep it on the palm of
your hand very quickly, because you didn‘t want any water that might be on
your hand to start the process. You dropped it into the test-tube, and the
water and the urine together triggered the necessary reaction which took place.
It generated enough heat to cause the mixture to boil, and cause the physical
changes - the chemical changes - that made the colour of the process change.
If it was completely free of sugar, the resulting colour would be blue, and
the tablets were a sort of speckled blue colour anyway. I think there was
copper sulphate in them, but I‘m not sure where I get that from. If there
was sugar present it would be somewhere on a coloured scale from a greeny-blue,
through a fairly solid green, to an orangey-green. And then at two percent
of sugar in the urine it would achieve a bright orange. If you managed to
get your urine to carry more than two percent of sugar, the bright orange
would become rather darker and brown, and it was really time to worry. But
a two percent score was easily enough
obtained; getting further than that was difficult. I imagine the kidneys
give up trying to get rid of sugar if there‘s too much of it. With hindsight,
it was altogether well organised. It was the result of somebody thinking
very carefully how to make urine more easily testable. There were major disadvantages.
I think the biggest
|
| | (7) disadvantage
was that, the way in which the kidneys get sugar out of the blood into the
urine does depend on a lot of things, including how much water there is in
your system. The thirst that comes with the high blood sugar doesn‘t always
lead you actually to drink, and I think if you‘re not actually drinking, some
of the sugar can get retained in the blood longer than it ought to. And there
was the diabetic journal used to wax on, from time to time, about the fact
that some people had kidneys which acted rather as a dam, and which would
not sieve out sugar as efficiently as they should do. With the hindsight
that I‘ve got now, I wouldn‘t be at all surprised if long-term diabetics might,
in fact, find it much less easy to get rid of sugar in this way, but it was
a guide. The biggest single problem was, if your urine had no sugar in it,
that did not mean... well, it meant that your insulin was acting effectively
enough, or you were having enough exercise and you weren‘t eating too much
food, but, on the other hand, you could get a perfectly normal blue result
and be on the verge of a hypo. And there was absolutely no way in which the
test could tell you that. It could only test for high sugar. It couldn‘t
test for low sugar in any way, because if you had a low blood sugar, your
urine wouldn‘t contain very much sugar, and that would be all you could learn.
The other thing, of course, is it‘s perfectly possible to have sugar in your
urine, and at the same time to have blood sugar which is actually going down
dangerously. And knowing that meant that one never relied on the urine sugar
results too carefully.
You said that when you came out
of hospital you were nervous that you didn‘t know everything you needed to
know about diet. Can you remember what you were taught about diet in hospital?
I wasn‘t taught all that much
in hospital. I think the hospital dietitians may have been one half a step
ahead of where my parents were. Dr Lawrence always talked about things he
called portions, and a portion was enough food to produce ten grams of carbohydrate,
and you could have a half portion. And I remember, from before developing
diabetes, that one portion of potato was a potato the size of a hen‘s egg.
I remember my mother being terrified by the thought that you only needed a
very small weight indeed of currants or sultanas to qualify for a portion.
And at that stage, because nobody really understood it, there was absolutely
no suggestion that some... ten grams of carbohydrate in some foods were much
more harmful than ten grams of carbohydrate in others. I think my mother
probably realised
|
| | (8)
this. She certainly knew well enough that you shouldn‘t eat a very concentrated
lunch, consisting mainly of things with very high carbohydrate content, and
no fibre or other contents. You know, lunch composed entirely of shortbread
biscuits, for example, would have the danger that it would almost certainly
work through your body very quickly and well before the next meal, and your
blood sugar would be on the way down again. She was aware of that. I suppose
you could say that, if you like, she knew something about the glycaemic index
concept for herself, forty or fifty years ahead of her time. But the dietitians
made no distinction. And, for example, I knew that if I actually helped myself
to a handful of sultanas out of the relevant jar in the kitchen, it didn‘t
appear to lead to my having a high blood sugar. I now know why that is so.
At the time, I thought "well, fancy that - it doesn‘t happen for me",
and thought no more about it. The dietitians in the hospital had decided,
for the sake of ease - or for some reason or other - to call Dr Lawrence‘s
portions black lines, and a black line was ten grams of carbohydrate in one
form or another. They‘d also developed a statement on the diet sheet my mother
was given, which talked about the number of red lines I ought to consume -
a red line being a mixture of so many grams of protein and so many grams of
fat. And to this day, I‘m not sure whether the red lines she was being asked
to control as well were a matter of making sure that diabetics didn‘t die
of under nourishment, because they were just controlling their black lines
and not eating enough protein, or whether, in fact, this was an early sign
of a belief that it was possible to eat too much protein and fat as well.
I rather think it was the former. I think they were aiming to deal with under
nourishment among Sheffield‘s diabetic classes, and certainly
I think my mother‘s interest in red lines was never terribly strong. My father‘s
view of it was that it... the methods they‘d used before had worked all right
with my brother, and it wasn‘t going to be really worthwhile trying to invent
new controls as well. So, in a sense, it was very much easier for me to simply
conform to the family‘s view of the diabetic diet, which was, in any case,
not out of line, and to forget about these red lines altogether. And I don‘t
remember hearing much about red lines, so they may have been a local invention
rather than a national one.
Did you find it hard to adjust
to a strict diet?
Yes, I think it wasn‘t easy.
I think the hardest piece of adjustment was really getting as good as I could
about avoiding sugar, in its various forms, which was very much more a matter
of the fact that if you eat a lot of sugar, it disturbs your insulin balance
and can leave you burnt out an hour or two later, when it shouldn‘t. I broke
all the rules I could when I was a teenager. Looking back, I‘m ashamed of
how much I broke some of them. I think I was fortunate that, since I was
only breaking them for my own pleasure, some of the things I cheated on were
actually not as harmful as they might have been. I mean, to this day, if
I need to eat something quickly to counteract a low blood sugar, I‘m very
likely to go for a Bounty bar, which has a nice core of coconut and a chocolate
casing round it. And I used to eat these when I was a schoolboy, knowing
that I was doing wrong, knowing that I was taking in sugar that wasn‘t going
to do me any good. But actually, I wouldn‘t be at all surprised if the glycaemic
index of a Bounty bar isn‘t too bad. And, you know, it contains enough sugar
to deal with a low blood sugar, if you‘ve got it, but it doesn‘t actually
build as high a blood sugar afterwards as it might. And that was purely a
matter of personal preference. And I have to admit, it was milk chocolate
Bounty bars only, until fairly recent times, when I discovered the plain chocolate
Bounty bar, which is even nicer - not to worry!
|
| | (9)
What was it like going back to school after you came out of hospital?
Fairly difficult. I think I‘d
missed a week of school less than a month before, and then a fortnight of
school actually in hospital being balanced off. And the academic pressures
on me were very considerable indeed - I had to catch up pretty quickly. The
actual process of coming to terms with diabetes in the context of school,
I can‘t remember any real difficulties. It all seemed to make reasonably
good sense. I didn‘t have my first hypo at school for quite some time. It
was March when I went back to school... no, early April when I went back to
school, Easter holidays intervened fairly quickly, and I think I didn‘t have
my first hypo at school until some time after the beginning of the summer
term. Ended up unconscious - with a rather angry form master wondering what
he had to do and getting organised - and the brief that had been given to
the school secretary in the office being dug out and acted upon and so forth;
and it all worked out fairly badly. It was my first experience of having
a hypo which actually went too far, and I can‘t remember very much about it,
except that it was, I suppose, one of about half a dozen hypos in the rest
of my time at school - which was quite a number of years - in which I actually
ended up unconscious. And most of these were in the first half of my time
at school, before I was sixteen, rather than after. Getting people to know
that I was diabetic is a subject that I‘ve always rather tried to avoid doing
too much of. I don‘t like drawing myself to other people‘s attention saying
"I‘m a diabetic - look at me", and so I tended not to wax on about
being diabetic more than I had to. The school, on the other hand, took certain
steps to make sure that most of the staff - all the staff who taught me and
most of the others who would have contact with me - understood what diabetes
was and what to watch out for, which was the school doing very much on its
own initiative. It took the information my parents gave it, and made sure
that this information was freely available. The other thing I do remember
is that, because of being diabetic, it was decided that I would be put on
a very, very short list of people who would not be caned if they committed
offences deserving caning. Nobody told me that I was on such a list. And
I can remember, on about three occasions, being sent to
|
| | (10)
fetch the cane, which was step one of the elaborate formal procedure the school
had for caning, which restricted the number of strokes to a maximum of four,
and only in really indictable offence cases, a requirement that the caning
should be witnessed by another master, and that the victim should go to fetch
the cane from the staff room and take the cane, and the slip that came with
it, duly completed and signed by both staff, take them back to the staff room.
And if your form master was the person who opened the staff room door when
you went to get the cane, you were in trouble twice over. And the three times
I was sent for the cane - after becoming diabetic - in each case, I was allowed
to go right through the process. And only when I‘d arrived back with the
slip and the cane, and been made to wait outside the classroom until the master
had reached the point at which he could come out and… only then did I find
out that I wasn‘t going to get caned. And the third time I thought to myself
"this is a bit odd - they always do that"! I was very lucky - I‘ve
never experienced corporal punishment in school, and I certainly deserved
it on three occasions, if not more. That was one of the steps the school
took, though: the idea that, because they‘d been informed of a situation -
it was highly professional school. It was the best school in Sheffield
at the time and I was proud of being a pupil there - and, you know, they dealt
with it exactly as they should have done. The other thing was that I… for
the whole of the rest of my time at school, the school kitchen arranged a
special alternative pudding course for me, to replace the plum duff, or whatever
stodge was being served up for the rest of the children. They perhaps were
a little dangerous in how they did this. They didn‘t use sugar, but I got
some fairly delectable choices presented to me. And I had to - in order to
pick this up each day - I would join the queue at the servery, and then make
my way into the kitchen behind the servery to pick up my pudding, and emerge
carrying it. This was a highly public sort of thing. Every boy in the school
pretty well knew that I went to collect a special pudding, and most of them
seemed to know that it was because of being diabetic. I also developed a
very close relationship with all the cooks in the kitchen, because they saw
me as this special young boy. And, you know, if I winked carefully at one
of them as she was serving up a vegetable I was particularly keen on, she
would make sure I got a decent sized helping and this sort of thing. I think
that‘s one of the terrible things about diabetic children: they do get an
awful
|
| | (11)
lot of adults fussing over them. They can easily get the idea that they‘re
somebody very special. And I think there are probably studies done by people
on whether diabetics are actually psychologically the same as other people
- life-time diabetics who‘ve been on insulin since being young. I was once
interviewed in the Warneford
Hospital in Oxford, by - which is the local mental hospital
- by a lady doing some sort of research into diabetes. To this day I don‘t
know what her conclusions were, but, you know, the fact of an interesting
sub-group, whose psychology may not be the same as other people‘s, because
their experiences have been different, was certainly something that existed
twenty years ago, and there may be something in it.
Were there any other boys in
the school with diabetes?
No, the school, I think, saw
its next diabetic pupil a year or two after I left it. That‘s an interesting
figure, because, I think, nowadays, a school with eight hundred pupils will
probably have more than one juvenile diabetic at once. I believe, of course,
one of the factors is that juvenile diabetes is more common among people of
Asian origin, and, in the fifties, there weren‘t very many Asians in Sheffield,
and not enough to have any significant effect. But, I think juvenile diabetes,
as a whole, was less common then, and, of course, because diabetes is an inherited
tendency - juvenile diabetes is an inherited tendency - it stands to reason:
I developed diabetes less than... just about thirty years after the first
insulin was administered to human beings, and so the gene pool didn‘t have
as much diabetes in it as it would have had in the last twenty years, reading
back from now. Worth mentioning, the early diabetes: the first person in
Sheffield to receive insulin was a man - who later was
a leader of several companies in Sheffield - called Sir
Stuart Goodwin. He was a man who gave a great deal of the money he accumulated
in his lifetime for charitable purposes, of one sort or another. And it‘s
of some interest that, having been injected with insulin for the first time,
probably weeks ahead of anyone else in this part of Britain, he survived the
vagaries of being an insulin dependent diabetic for the rest of his life,
and died in his eighties, after having made a major contribution to public
life in Sheffield.
|
| | (12)
It came as rather a surprise to me, when I was probably certainly not much
older than twenty, to discover that diabetes seemed to carry a range of complications
that led to early death. Yes, it was my late teens I discovered this. I
had it brought home when I first applied for a life insurance. But the first
I knew of it was when a chap, who had been treasurer of the local branch of
the Diabetic Association, died in his late thirties of heart attack, and my
mother said to me "yes, I‘m sorry to say it‘s one of the side effects
of diabetes". This hadn‘t got to me before that, and it came as rather
a surprise. The comfort is that although you do see a lot of diabetics who
are troubled with all sorts of life-threatening complications from diabetes,
you do also hear of diabetics who live well into their eighties and beyond.
And I think it‘s an interesting topic this, and it‘s one where I hope I‘m
on the right side of the equation here. It does appear to be more a matter
of luck than of anything else, whether or not you‘re going to suffer from
diabetic complications. The statisticians have made quite clear that one
of the things that helps you avoid diabetic complications is having had a
reasonably good control of your blood sugar levels - that if you don‘t control
your blood sugar levels, complications come thick and fast. People who don‘t
control their blood sugars reasonably well tend to have more complications,
even if they‘re lucky. The people who are most lucky of all, of the ones
who have this ‘missing in luck‘ factor, and also take reasonable care of controlling
their diabetes. I‘m very lucky, in this respect, myself; exceedingly lucky.
When I first arrived at the John Radcliffe Hospital in - no, sorry, it was
the Radcliffe Infirmary, then, in Oxford - early in my thirties, to sign on
as a patient there, I was seen by a young registrar called Jim Black, who
later was the author of the diabetic cookbook, and led a major movement towards
a new look at diet for diabetics. And Jim Black measured me in every respect
and took a history from me, and finally got out his ophthalmoscope and looked
in my eyes, and then called over a couple of medical students, and said "look
in this man‘s eyes and tell me how long you think he‘s been diabetic".
And their reply - after doing a not as good a
|
| | (13)
investigation of my eyes as he‘d done - their reply was "is he diabetic?".
Because then, as now - and I‘m talking of fifty years on insulin - there are
no signs of any failures in the retina that are normally associated with diabetes,
and which normally affect people after a very much shorter time than fifty
years. I find myself, also, as a patient of the kidney department in the
local hospital here, for reasons which are totally unconnected with my diabetes.
I‘m suffering from a kidney condition called membranous nephropathy, which
has a reasonably mixed outcome, but which is definitely seen as not being
in any way the result of my diabetes. And the kidney specialist there, many
of whose patients are diabetic patients with complications, they say to me
that if they find that somebody‘s eyes are completely clear of diabetic problems,
then their kidneys, likewise, will be clear of kidney problems. So, for some
reason, I‘ve been lucky enough to avoid the worst of the diabetic complications,
and this is after fifty years on insulin. It‘s after fifty years, when I‘ve
done my best to control my blood sugar for my own sake, but haven‘t always
been able to do it particularly well. I‘m sure there are other diabetics
whose blood sugar profiles are the same as mine, and who have been much less
fortunate. And it‘s a very interesting question, and I think if some researcher
can focus on that particular issue - of what it is that makes some diabetics
with very ordinary diabetic histories so much luckier than others, in terms
of complications - the research project could lead to real discoveries; be
worth doing.
Can you talk about managing diabetes
as a teenager?
Yes, I‘m not sure whether my
life as a teenager was particularly typical. I was at a fairly hard-working
school and was expected to work quite hard, and therefore didn‘t, I think,
test out the opportunities of life as much as I might have done if I‘d had
a different sort of childhood. I‘ve never been particularly great exerciser.
I don‘t think that my particular body is very good at gaining anything from
exercise. Over-exercising has only ever been uncomfortable for me. It‘s
never taken me through any sort of barrier, to a new feeling of excitement
or invigoration, and I‘ve never found myself getting fitter as a result of
exercising.
|
| | (14)
And what was your health like as a teenager?
Well, given that I wasn‘t a very
energetic teenager, generally I think my health was quite good. I didn‘t
have a lot of reasons for being off school, and completed my education without
any further big long interruptions. I‘ve got here a picture of the first
form, when I was eleven or twelve, probably just about at the time when I
was diagnosed diabetic. I‘m standing on the back row near the right hand
end, and I‘m the second tallest boy in a class of eleven and twelve year olds.
The following year‘s picture, which I haven‘t got, had me having been outstripped
in height by a good half dozen of my people of the same age, and having really,
in effect, stopped growing when I first developed diabetes. And that remained
until well into the following year, when, after this long cessation of growing,
I suddenly started growing again, and reached my present height of six foot
three some time after most of the other boys in the class had stopped growing.
That goes along with having had my voice break at the age of fifteen and a
half, when, at the time when I was a boy, the average age for voices breaking
was thirteen or nearly fourteen. And I‘m sure that the effects of diabetes,
as a teenager, included the late maturing process as well. So, in a sense,
my underlying health and fitness were not terribly good, and there was a definite
cessation of the growing process, which meant that I was pretty weedy altogether
when I was moving out of the third form into the fourth form, and then, as
I say, this late spurt started, which took me up to a reasonable height without
difficulty.
|
| | (15)
During your teens, did you drink or smoke or do any other teenage activities?
Well, I did quite a lot of teenage
activities. I never drank very heavily - probably, more than anything else,
‘cause I‘m not at all keen on the idea of being drunk and risking the complications
that can cause. I‘ve never ever in my life been more than a bit merry. And
I did less than my share of underage drinking - didn‘t really get a taste
for alcohol of any sort until I went to college, and then never drank heavily.
I smoked heavily from an early age, I guess. My elder brother had - I‘m sure
my parents were completely wrong about this, and would have done otherwise
if they‘d thought about it - because he couldn‘t eat sweets, my mother allowed
my elder brother to smoke at home, probably from the age of thirteen onwards,
which was bad news. She never allowed me to smoke at home in the same way,
until I left school and took to smoking a pipe. But I‘d been one of the squad
of young people who would smoke on the way home from school, despite the school‘s
requirement that we should not do so in school uniform, which, since we‘d
stopped wearing caps, merely meant taking one‘s school tie off at the beginning
of the walk down the last road homewards. And I think the main reason why
I took to smoking a pipe when I left school was because I realised that, without
the requirements of the school that I shouldn‘t smoke at school, I would probably
become a twenty a day man in no time if I stuck to cigarettes. I smoked a
pipe from then until my mid thirties, when, under pressure from my wife who
had given up six months before, I finally managed to get it all together and
give up smoking. Within a year of that, she even started smoking again, but
I managed to stay off the weed and haven‘t smoked since.
Did you have any girlfriends
in your teens?
Yes, quite a string of girlfriends
- one or two slightly longer term, one or two fairly short-term. On the whole,
I think most of them didn‘t really get terribly involved in my diabetes.
I think it was rather less public then than it became later. And in the modern
environment, I‘m doing four blood tests a day and four injections of insulin
a day, and necessarily I‘m with people when most of these take place. In
those days, I did a urine test from time to time, but the injections were
morning and evening only, and so it wasn‘t as much public as it has become
since. I think most of my girlfriends had to come to terms with the possibility
of hypos. My mother would, whenever she could, brief them on exactly what
to watch out for and so on, and, I suppose, most of them had one reason or
another to actually see me having a hypo, although for most of that time of
my life I was able to spot the hypo and deal with it, without actually becoming
unconscious. I don‘t think being diabetic made me more attractive to anybody,
and might even have been one of the factors bringing some friendships to an
end fairly quickly; I don‘t know.
|
| | (16)
What did you do after you left school?
Well, I left school shortly before
Christmas, in an academic year which I‘d been very much the oldest boy in
the school, having decided to try yet once more to get a place at university.
I was awarded a place in November and left school fairly quickly, and had
several months to fill before actually going to college in the following October.
I spent those months working as a temporary clerical apprentice, for seven
pounds eighteen shillings and four pence ha‘penny a week, for a steel company
on the border between Sheffield and Rotherham.
Most of the steel producing capacity has gone, and it‘s now the home of an
enormous museum, which is well worth a visit, for anyone who‘s listening.
I worked in a work study department, initially simply carrying out various
tasks requiring my skills and abilities, and gradually learning the basic
techniques of work study and beginning to do several fairly useful small scale
projects there. I then left school, had a summer holiday, which was very
pleasant, and went off to university in October 1961 as an undergraduate.
I don‘t suppose my first experience of employment was particularly typical,
but it was of interest to me. I‘d certainly decided that steel making was
a nice way of being employed. There‘s a magic about the sight of liquid metal,
which stays with people for the rest of their lives, I think. And it‘s very
sad that there‘s far less steel made in the Sheffield
area, now, than there used to be; indeed, far less made in Britain than there used to
be. At the end of my first year in university, I got a job for six weeks
in the same steel works as a temporary student, which meant I was downgraded
to a pay rate of seven pounds a week, because temporary students weren‘t seen
as being worth as much as temporary clerical apprentices. And then, the following
summer, I realised that I could have earned more money, more quickly, in another
way, and I worked for two weeks only, during the annual shutdown of the steel
works, as a temporary coppersmith‘s mate. This involved twelve hours work
per day for seven days a week for the fourteen days of the shutdown, during
which time, three other students and I accompanied the four coppersmiths all
over the steel works, while they carried out the tasks that a coppersmith
does, and engaged in a certain amount of sitting about, waiting for something
to happen. During which time, we discovered that one of the other three students
had just succeeded in selling what sounds - even by today‘s scale - a very
modernistic piece of art for an enormous price, which meant that the hundred
pounds he and we were each going to earn in the fortnight, was dwarfed by
the sum he was going to get for this little artistic production, which he‘d
knocked up with a hammer, nails and some paints one evening, a few months
before.
|
| | (17)
When you went away from home to university, what was it like not having your
mother there?
I think, on the whole, I had
been very well prepared for going away from home for the first time properly.
My parents had always taken the view that the diabetic has to be his own doctor,
certainly day to day and week to week, and they‘d done their level best to
make sure that I had everything I needed to be able to look after myself.
So, going away from home to university, there were many other adjustments
that were at least as difficult as any adjustment I had to do on the diabetic
front. You asked about my mother. I think it‘s fair to say that in talking
about my parents‘ involvement in my life, I‘ve sometimes referred to my mother
more than to my father. The obvious reason for this is because my mother
was simply the one who worried. She worried about me all the time. I think,
on the whole, she really only got rid of the worries when she finally saw
me married off, although she also was able to get rid of the worries, most
of the time, when I was away at college or otherwise in the hands of other
people. She worried far more than she should have done, and I think in that
respect, she‘s just the same as everybody else. I feel very sorry for a mother
who has a diabetic child. It‘s a constant worry. I think, probably, most
mothers worry even more than they should, although heaven knows, there are
enough things to worry about. I think most people feel that hypos can lead
to long periods with the brain having its supply of sugar interrupted and
brain damage and possibly worse. And to be honest, you don‘t very often read
of people who actually have died as a result of hypos, and you don‘t very
often read of people whose life has been substantially changed by the effect
of hypos. And I‘ve got a feeling that the body may actually be rather better
at protecting itself in that situation than a lot of us are led to believe.
I don‘t know whether the actual effects of continued and repeated hypos has
been properly worked out by research into what actually happens to people,
and maybe there are an awful lot of mothers who are worrying more about hypos
than they ought to.
Did you have many hypos when
you were at university?
Not really at university - relatively
few. I was already, then, getting to the stage where I could spot a hypo
coming a long way ahead. I do remember, however, in my
|
| | (18)
second year at college, having a hypo while driving a car, during which I
had a very slight impact with a car - which stopped in front of me at traffic
lights - whilst still conscious, and was virtually just drifting away when
the police were called and I was apprehended. I was arrested by a nice policeman,
who took very careful notes of what I had to say to him. And I found myself
in court, eventually, on a charge of driving without due care and attention,
which pleased me greatly, because the alternative charge would have been driving
under the influence of drink or drugs. And the statement I gave him at the
time was mainly designed to persuade him that, although the drugs I was on
had caused my condition, they weren‘t drugs of the sort that the charge would
have been based on. I was banned from driving for a month and fined fifteen
pounds, I think, by magistrates, whose main purpose, I think, was to keep
me off the road until the end of term. And a solicitor, who‘s just retired,
earned his share of the fees by making an excellent plea in mitigation, which
probably saved me from anything worse. I learnt a great deal then, and I‘ve
never ever had any other problem while driving, as a result of always being
aware of the need for care in that respect.
Did you have any evidence from
a doctor in court?
No, because I pleaded guilty,
because the charge was a fairly straightforward one. The court hearing was
really just a matter of the policeman giving his account of the incident,
my solicitor producing his brilliant plea in mitigation, and the magistrates
coming to a decision about what to do. And, you know, I‘d brought it on myself,
and I can‘t say anything but that I was very well treated, considering. It
could so easily have been far, far more disastrous, and I‘m glad to say nobody
was hurt, and even the damage I caused was relatively slight.
How did you manage your diet
while you were at university?
By the normal processes I had
learnt, of making sure I didn‘t stray too far without making sure I‘d had
a proper meal, making sure, if there was any doubt about it, that there would
be an appropriate form of carbohydrate for me to focus on in the meal, which
was easy when I was eating in college, because, you know, normal mass catering
- you don‘t get very far if you don‘t give young healthy undergraduates their
supply of potatoes, rice, or whatever it might be. So, I didn‘t have
|
| | (19)
a great deal of difficulty. I discovered Chinese food immediately before
I went to university, and I found myself able to cope nicely in the rather
undocumented world of what you get when you eat a Chinese meal - learning
the importance of a good bowl of rice as part of the make-up of it, and learning
that sweet and sour is not a good idea, because of the concentration of sugar
in it. And, on the whole, I think I‘ve spent my life, as far as possible,
eating what was given to me, and not fussing about it. The only question
I ever ask is to make sure - if there‘s any doubt about it at all - that there
will be enough carbohydrate for me to counteract the insulin dosage I would
normally have. And in the modern world, not eating puddings isn‘t particularly
odd anyway, so I don‘t have any real difficulty.
How much contact did you have
with the medical profession while you were a student?
Relatively little. I tended
to go to the diabetes clinic when at home during vacations, rather than at
university. I was required by my college to register with a local doctor
when I got there. In the course of my time there, I think I only consulted
him after breaking my nose, when going to sleep as I was walking around the
quadrangle late at night. When I went to see him, he looked me up and down
and said "well, yes, you‘ve broken your nose", and I said "well,
what are you going to do about it?". He said "I don‘t do anything
about it. I‘m afraid you just come to terms with it. If you find yourself
unable to breathe, we can engage in expensive and difficult and dangerous
surgery, but if you don‘t find yourself unable to breathe, then carry on living".
He had played rugger for the college thirty years before, and had a nose that
looked positively misshapen, so I don‘t think I was contacting the right professional
if I wanted anything other than a simple rough diagnosis.
|
| | (20)
What did you do after university?
I visited America, where my late elder
brother was a stockbroker on Wall Street. Spent three weeks there, and travelled
from - pretty well - from New England down to South Carolina and back, as well as spending a
lot of time in New York, where he
lived. And then returned to England
to start as a graduate apprentice with, what was then, Britain‘s largest steel company.
We made an eighth of the country‘s steel in the various plants we had around
the north of England, and the company formed
the backbone of BSC when steel was nationalised later on. I had been awarded
a graduate apprenticeship, which effectively meant that, for a year, I spent
my time in a mixture of lectures and in classrooms for a week or two at a
time, and working attachments in various parts of the country - where I would
get a chance to look at various different parts of the steel works and various
different parts of the country - before finally being appointed to a job in
one of them at the end of the time. The beginning of those working attachments
was a period of four weeks, right at the beginning of the graduate apprenticeship.
And during those four weeks I was required to spend my time working on shifts
as a labourer in a steel melting shop - in my case in Workington in West Cumberland
- getting up at six o‘clock in the morn... or getting up in time for the six
o‘clock shift in the morning, or working from two pm to ten pm, or working
on the night shift from ten till six. I had a tremendous time, and worked
very carefully on one of the country‘s acid Bessemer converter furnaces.
There weren‘t very many Bessemer converters in those days, and the furnace on which I worked
is now in a museum in Sheffield, having been taken there
when the melting shop concerned was closed down. I‘ve only visited it once,
but it gave me an interesting mixture of feelings, to see this enormous old
converter sitting there with people looking at it as an interesting architectural
industrial monument.
How did you manage shift work
as a diabetic?
I only really did that spell
of shift work, and the answer is it was much the same as anything else. You
have to be able to cope with the disturbances of life by understanding what
each disturbance could do to you, and making sure you‘re properly protected.
I‘m proudest of my ability to fly across time zones on long journeys by air.
I have, in my time, flown from between New
York and London several times, and
have also flown between Britain and Texas, Britain and Los Angeles. In each case, one tries to be... one needs to make sure
that the airline is capable of feeding one at the times when one wants it,
rather than when it suits them, and one has to be able to cope with the possible
lengthening or shortening of the intervals between successive injections.
It‘s easier, now, on a four injections a day basis than it was in the days
when I was on two a day. And I‘ve always been rather proud of the fact that
I don‘t appear to suffer too badly from jetlag, because a body whose internal
clock is largely controlled by the regular doses of insulin doesn‘t have the
problems of an adaptation when compared with the body that‘s actually looking
at whether the sun‘s risen or not. If my body thinks it‘s night time, it
treats it like night time. It makes it easier rather than harder, I think.
|
| | (21)
Did you tell people at work that you were diabetic?
I haven‘t always made a point
of telling people at work that I‘m diabetic, because of the desire not to
get into "I‘m a diabetic - look at me". I do, however… I‘ve learnt
very young that it‘s a good thing to make sure that somebody knows I‘m diabetic,
and I usually can spot very quickly the person who I ought to tell. It‘s
probably a lady, because ladies take this sort of thing much more responsibly
than gentlemen do. If she‘s the boss‘s secretary, so much the better, because
it‘ll get thrown into her lap anyway if anything goes wrong. And I‘ve tried
to... I think one of the reasons for being shy about it when I was younger
was that, on the whole, a lot of people hadn‘t heard about diabetes. I, not
very long ago, I heard Professor Matthews, in Oxford, speaking to a lay audience
about diabetes, and saying to them that... explaining to them why he appears
in one of the Morse novels in his own right, as Professor Matthews, with a
very accurate description of him written by Colin Dexter. And he explained
that Colin Dexter was one of his patients, and had done this out of the goodness
of his heart, and that Morse was a diabetic. He then started his proper speech
to the group he was addressing by saying "hands up anyone who doesn‘t
know somebody who‘s diabetic", and only a very few hands went up. And
he said to them "well, you ought to know somebody, because I‘ve just
been talking about Colin Dexter". But, in fact, the question was obviously
taken by most people as "do you know somebody among your family and friends
who‘s diabetic?", and in the modern world, most people do. Very often,
people have a relation who‘s diabetic, but those who don‘t have a relation
who‘s diabetic usually know of somebody whose life‘s been affected by it.
And that makes it easier for me to say to people "I‘m a diabetic on insulin".
They‘ve read enough, they‘ve heard enough to be able to take that, and any
other sentence I want to say, without, at the time, treating me as though
I‘ve got some new form of disease that they‘ve never heard of or understood.
|
| | (22)
When you met your wife, how did she react to your having diabetes?
We met very shortly before I
took my final exams. I don‘t think she knew anybody who was diabetic, and
it came as a bit of a surprise to her. Like so many other people, she found
it to be something she had to take on board, and she managed very well. I
think her mother was rather more concerned than she, because of what she had
heard about diabetes. And her mother actually went so far as to consult a
doctor, and then to persuade us to go and see the doctor, so that he could
talk to us together about it, and then presumably provide feedback for my
prospective mother-in-law. And I think, probably, the thing that she worried
most of all about was that I‘d mentioned, almost in passing, the fact that
I‘d heard that there was some chance that diabetics might be relatively unfertile,
and the thought of not having grandchildren had obviously upset her quite
a bit, and she wanted to know more about this. The doctor she consulted was
a reasonably prestigious one with a good reputation, and he was able to advise
her that that was unlikely to be a great problem, and that, on the whole,
she needn‘t worry. He also advised her, as was appropriate at that stage,
that it looked as though the chances were quite reasonable that our children
wouldn‘t include a diabetic among their numbers. As it happens, it didn‘t
turn out that way. I have two daughters, both now in their thirties, and
my younger daughter, after a period during which she had been, shall we say,
generously built rather than underweight, was diagnosed at the beginning of
her thirties as possibly suffering from diabetes. And the tests showed that
she was indeed suffering from diabetes, which was held to be adult-onset diabetes,
and was treated without insulin for a period of over a year, during which,
the relative lack of control got worse, and it became clear that she was actually
a genuinely insulin dependent diabetic. It‘s not just a case of diabetes,
which is so badly controlled, that insulin is the easiest way of bringing
it back under control. Her pancreas had spent that year going out of condition,
and it was stopping working. I‘m glad to say that she‘s adapted to diabetes
very well. She‘s, again, had even more
|
| | (23)
than I have of the example of another diabetic in her family going before
and blazing the trail. She understood, right from the start, the importance
of the various things that a diabetic can do to help themselves. And particularly
since she got onto insulin, and the insulin took control of her condition,
she‘s been able to keep a reasonably stable life. She became pregnant shortly
after my wife died - the beginning of 2003 - and was immediately put in the
hands of her diabetic specialist and the maternity department at the local
hospital working in tandem, seeing both of them whenever she went for a pre-natal
appointment. They gave her very strict guidelines on how to control her diabetes
to a much tighter requirements than everyday diabetes requires, so as to make
sure that the foetus doesn‘t get too much sugar in the mother‘s blood, and
rub its hands - metaphorically - and say "right, goody, let‘s take some
of this" and produce an enormous baby. And my grandson, Ivor, was born
a couple of weeks early, weighing six stone thirteen - six pounds thirteen,
sorry - which is absolutely bang on for a normal baby. And for a baby with
a diabetic mother is a very considerable achievement, because it means that
his size development over the whole period, which was being monitored regularly
by ultrasonic tests, had kept properly under control, because she had been
able to control her diabetic condition to these very tight requirements laid
down by the specialists. We were very pleased about that altogether.
For the historical record, have
you noticed any difference in her approach to diabetes from your early approach?
Yes, I‘ve steered fairly clear
of requiring her to answer to me in this respect at all. She was very worried
when they finally said "right, let‘s put you on insulin". She was
very worried about whether or not she was going to be able to cope. She was
effectively sent home from the hospital one Friday with a supply of insulin
and instructions to start injecting it. And I think she‘d had a bit of a
lesson on how to do it with distilled water, but that‘s as far as it went.
And in order to help her, I spent that weekend with her at her house - with
her and her husband at her house - helping her through the processes of coming
to terms with how it all worked, and whether or not she could manage. And
I really tried very hard not to
|
| | (24)
lay down how I thought she should do things, because it‘s much more important
that she learns to do it for herself, and that she takes the advice of her
doctors, rather than of a hoary old diabetic with different requirements.
But she‘s very laid back about it; she manages very nicely. She‘s much more
able to cope with disturbances to her daily routine than I am, and I think
she‘s learnt how to cope with them by actually letting them happen and adjusting
to them on the hoof. I tend… occasionally I‘m prepared to take a meal very
much earlier than I should or very much later than I should, and time the
insulin to go with it. She very often doesn‘t get home from work until very
late. Although it‘s planned, it means that very often, if she wants to eat
with her husband, they won‘t eat until ten pm, and is able to cope with this
without difficulty, even if it means adjusting the timing and quantity of
her insulin, and eating a little bit of food without an injection and then
more later, and this sort of thing. She manages very well and it doesn‘t
disturb her; she‘s in touch with it. She also has the comfort of being able
to diagnose her own hypos when they happen without difficulty. I switched
to human insulin some time, I think, in the seventies, when it first became
available - if it was the seventies; it was about then. Had a few hiccups
in the early stages, because, if a doctor prescribed insulin of a certain
sort, there was a period of about nine months when the pharmaceutical wholesalers
would send down a batch of insulin, regardless of whether it used the word
human on the packet or not. And this meant that you were quite likely to
get switched back from human to ordinary pig‘s insulin, and then switched
again to human insulin after a month or two. And I had a certain amount of
difficulty with this. But the thing that everybody said about human insulin
was that it worked better than pig‘s insulin, because it was biologically
more closely tailored, and that it made it much less easy to detect a hypo
coming on. And I have to say that I never found this. I found that the traditional
signs of a hypo worked just as well for me. I‘ve always found the best sign
of all being the fact that I find it difficult, when my blood sugar‘s getting
low, to do relatively simple things of the brain like mental arithmetic.
I‘m reasonably good at mental arithmetic normally, but if my blood sugar‘s
low, I become a lot less good at it, and this is an easy guide for me. And
I have to say, I don‘t think human insulin made a lot of difference to me
in that respect. In that respect, as with others, I may have been lucky.
|
| | (25)
Has the way your insulin has been supplied changed over the years?
Yes, indeed. In the early days
- in the fifties - I actually obtained my insulin from the pharmacist at the
hospital, where I attended an outpatients‘ clinic. It was prescribed for
me by the doctor I was seeing, and I would go home with my supply of insulin
and other equipment. When health service prescription charges came in, I
was required to put a shilling in a machine and out came a stamp to stamp
onto the prescription before I handed it to the pharmacist. The stamp said
"prescription fee paid", and you paid one prescription fee per prescription,
rather than per item on the prescription. The fee, I think, disappeared after
a change of government. And by the time it came back - which was the first
time that diabetics found themselves not being charged prescription charges
- by the time it came back, the general tradition or general system had been
developed, whereby the hospital might advise on your drug intake, but the
prescription process had to be done by your GP. And, on the whole, hospital
pharmacies found themselves much less busy when they were only prescribing
drugs for patients who were actually in hospital. The real irritation with...
I mean, it‘s worth saying that diabetes is exceptionally expensive for the
Health Service, not least because of the number of people in other departments,
for example the kidney departments, whose presence there as patients arises
simply from the complications of their diabetes. On that basis, an increase
in the number of diabetics in the country is a major disaster. Having said
that, the Health Service has, at times, been remarkably unhelpful to diabetics.
I‘ve mentioned the damage caused to my flesh by injections with, what I can
only call, coarse bore needles when I was a teenager. The ultimate insult
was the period immediately before disposable syringes were first supplied
to diabetics, when the Diabetic Association managed to make the point to the
government that if drug addicts were gong to be given disposable syringes
for free, it wasn‘t just inappropriate, it was an actual insult to Britain‘s
diabetics to make them pay for their own disposable syringes. And the fact
that they were persuaded to change their minds and diabetics were given free
disposable syringes, has led me, like an awful lot of other diabetics, to
be much more parsimonious with my use of disposable syringes. My daughter
throws the syringe away after a couple of uses. I get a prescription for
a hundred, and normally expect to make them last well over twelve months,
and tend only to change the disposable needles on my insulin pen when the
cartridge of insulin that I‘m injecting has finally run out.
|
| | (26)
Another change there‘s been, of course, is that the Health Service has tended
to ration or to control the issue of prescribed drugs to diabetics, in a way
which seems to me to be very much a second order level of economy. A diabetic
is going to use a certain amount of insulin and other requirements during
a year, and I can‘t see that it‘s necessarily very clever to change the amount
of time for which one prescription can be issued downwards. In the old days,
one was able to get at least three months‘ supply of any particular item on
a single prescription. And I used - like a lot of diabetics - I used to go
and see my doctor about four times a year, and collect a complete batch of
everything in sight, the appropriate quantities for everything, and I would
only waste the doctor‘s time for three or four minutes, at most, in doing
this. And if he wanted to take another minute looking at the state of my
health generally, he would do. As things stand now, the doctor has to prescribe
not more than two months worth of any particular item. There is pressure,
I gather, in some areas - although I‘ve never experienced it - for diabetics
to use less test strips for blood tests than they ought to use, because every
test strip costs a significant amount of money. And the less tests a diabetic
does, the less money is spent under that heading. The problem is that the
less tests a diabetic does, the less control he has over his diabetic condition,
and that‘s bad news. Likewise, maybe the country only needs to have an average
of say four to six weeks worth of insulin in the hands of every diabetic,
but if there were a fire in the insulin factories - of the sort that prevented
the supply of Branston pickle a few months ago - would we actually all be
able to cope and all be able to get enough insulin to meet the needs within
that period of six weeks? It‘s a good thing to have quite a lot of insulin
available in the hands of the people who are going to need it.
Has that been a fear at the back
of your mind, that one day there might not be a supply of insulin?
No, I think not. I think it
would be a significant emergency that would require urgent steps if that were
to happen. It has, however, been a thought at the back of my mind at all
times that it would be necessary to make sure that my own supply of insulin
was relatively large. And I‘m afraid, at any moment in time, I tend to be
absolutely sure that I‘ve got more than six weeks worth, rather than less.
|
| | (27)
Can you talk about what your diabetic control has been like in middle age?
Yes, in middle age, from sort
of my... until after my ... well, till some way into my forties, I did relatively
little actual testing as part of the control process. The only option available
at the beginning of that time was the Clinitest tablets for testing urine,
which were never terribly convenient. You did really need somewhere you could
carry out a minor laboratory exercise, and under the modern Health and Safety
at Work Act, they‘d probably be illegal to do it in an office anyway. And
I think also the fact that at that stage in my life, I could come up with
a reasonably good guess as to what my blood sugar was. I would have a doctor
take a blood sample for eventual determination on my blood sugar, and I‘d
be able to make a prediction of what the score would be, which would quite
often be surprisingly accurate. I should say that when I started as a diabetic,
the blood testing process was incredibly long-winded. I would arrive at the
diabetic clinic. A specially sterile needle would be used to dig a hole in
the end of a finger, and blood would be squeezed out of it into a very small
test-tube, probably to, you know, half an inch deep in this small test-tube.
It would then be corked up and sent off to the laboratory, and the blood sugar
content would be available less than twenty four hours later. And this was
the very latest technology, and absolutely useless as far as being able to
make a quick correction to one‘s insulin dosage in order to meet one‘s needs.
I had to have something better than that, and, as I say, the Clinitest process
wasn‘t incredibly reliable, and tended to give you a view of your history
over the last few hours, rather than your present state. And I went through
most of my twenties and thirties, and into my forties, relying mainly on my
own appreciation of how my blood sugar was. I felt the symptoms of high blood
sugar quite easily. My bladder told me that it was filling up faster than
usual, and I would feel less good with a high blood sugar than I normally
do, and I could recognise a hypo coming on, and gauge where I was on the scale
between the two. And the decision to start blood testing didn‘t really hit
me until I was over forty, when a period of... a very bad dose of something
- a year when the ‘flu vaccination, that I‘ve always been able to get, turned
out not to be the right ‘flu vaccination for the ‘flu that was going round
my part of the world - led to me being stuck in
|
| | (28)
bed with the ‘flu, which made me totally unable to eat. And I‘d done then,
what I should have… what I‘d always understood I should do if unable to eat,
which was to halve the dosage of insulin I was using. And this actually led
me to have a dangerously high blood sugar, at a time when I was feeling too
ill to be able to take notice of it. And when visited by the GP, who was
called in by my wife, I found myself being sent to the nearest hospital -
not by an ambulance, but in a police paddy wagon, because the ambulance drivers
were on strike that weekend - and being admitted straight into hospital, and
brought round from considerable dehydration and a very high blood sugar -
far higher than I‘ve probably ever had before or since. And at that time,
it was brought to my notice that my main objections to the urine testing system
could be completely overcome by making use of the then still relatively recent
introduction of portable blood test kits. And I got my first BM test kit,
which took over a minute to produce a result, but did - heaven knows how accurate
it was - but did at least give you an estimate of your blood sugar. And I
started to use this, and developed a system for keeping track of my blood
sugar, which I‘ve used ever since. At that stage, I was still using two injections
a day of mixed short acting and long acting insulin, and the control I got
was not as brilliant as it could have been. I didn‘t move to my present regime
of four injections of insulin per day - one before each meal, and one long
acting insulin before I go to bed - I didn‘t move to that until the early
nineties, when my condition needed a look at, and the recommendation was that
I should switch to this as a means of better control. Compared with my youth,
the modern environment is much better. I have blood test results in twelve
seconds, I can make sensible decisions about the insulin dosage I‘m going
to have, in the context of the blood sugar results and what I expect to be
eating and doing in the next few hours. I can use a cartridge pen, which
is so quick compared with other methods for getting an injection in. The
biggest delay is when I‘m about to go to bed, having to upturn it in order
to make sure that the insulin is properly mixed during the day. I sort of
draw the cartridge up and stick it in, and it‘s all done in a few seconds.
The needle I use is a twenty six gauge one, which is so thin my body doesn‘t
notice it going into the folds of fat on my tum. Compared with the hassle
of being a diabetic in the old days - and making sure one has a supply of
surgical spirit to keep one‘s syringe and needle in, of dealing with the Clinitest
system, of everything like that - the modern world is much, much better, and
I wouldn‘t dream of the good old days in any respect.
|
| | (29)
Over the many years that you‘ve had diabetes, have you noticed any changes
in the way medical staff treat patients?
I think the biggest single change
is that they used to treat me like a small boy and now they treat me like
an old grandpa. I think that‘s entirely appropriate. I think when you consider
how much trouble a diabetic can be, diabetics get very nicely treated by the
medical staff they meet. I think… I do find, nowadays, that some of the young
medics I meet are actually using the opportunity to find out more about their
craft by asking me questions about the way I‘ve gone through things in the
past. I think there is no doubt about it, that the diabetics in Britain
are very fortunate, in that we do have... the Health Service has to recognise
us as a major area for treatment. They can‘t afford to sweep us under the
carpet and forget about us, and so they do take it seriously. I think the
initiatives on setting standards for the treatment of diabetes really are
perhaps not as necessary as they might have been, because there‘s always been
so much co-operation and so forth going on anyway. And I think it‘s an interesting
reflection that nobody in their right mind would consider asking for private
patient treatment as a diabetic, because of doubts about what the Health Service
offers them. The Health Service, on the whole, hospitalises diabetics even
less now than it used to, because there‘s less need to hospitalise diabetics.
And I think, in exchange, they give us a very, very good service as outpatients
and so forth. I think, in some ways, it‘s a bit taxing. I‘ve always taken
the view that it‘s better for me to consult a diabetes centre in a major hospital
about my diabetes than to sign up with the diabetes clinic that my GP might
be using for quite a lot of his ordinary patients. I don‘t know whether my
firm belief that this is what suits me best is necessarily a belief that I
feel should apply to everybody. If I was right, then there ought to be big
diabetes centres every few miles in big cities, and not have individual GP
practices trying to deal with their few dozen diabetics individually. But
I‘m not sure that I‘ve got it right. I do feel, however, that the great thing
about the modern treatment, compared with the old treatment, is that diabetes
is obviously much more visible to the average health professional. I do remember
hearing cases, when I was a boy, of GPs who had children, who were obviously
suffering from something, and after several weeks of consultation by the parents
found themselves having it suggested to them that perhaps the child might
be diabetic. I remember one friend, when I was a school boy, being diagnosed
as being diabetic by his best friend, who was a diabetic, and who said let
me test your urine with my Clinitest set. The doctor concerned was horrified
to discover that this had happened, and that the result was a very clear indication.
The thought that the child might be diabetic hadn‘t crossed the doctor‘s mind.
That‘s the way the health service was in the 1950s, I guess.
|
| | (30)
Can you describe a typical day in your life now, in 2005?
Yes, I‘m sixty two and I‘m still
working. I‘m a self-employed management consultant, which means I don‘t have
a regular job to go to. At the moment, and for the last three months... well,
two months and for the next month and a half, I‘m actually commuting daily
by train from Sheffield to Durham,
doing a relatively interesting - to me - job, in the IT department of a major
water undertaking up there. And I leave the house at twenty to seven in the
morning, and get home at seven thirty in the evening. And I wouldn‘t dream of doing
a job like that for twelve months on end, but for a few months it‘s possible,
and it pays well. When that finishes, I shall probably get a short break,
and then hopefully find somebody else who wants to buy my abilities for a
few weeks or months. I don‘t take enough exercise - everybody says I don‘t
take enough exercise. I‘m well built, but not unduly overweight, I like to
think. I, having been widowed nearly two years ago, I married for the second
time a few months ago. I married one of my very oldest friends - a girl who
was a close friend of my first wife‘s and my own for many years. My first
wife was godmother to my stepson. And, in many ways, I think she‘s taken
on quite a lot in taking on the job of being a wife of a diabetic. I think
it isn‘t only the mothers of diabetics who have a lot to cope with. I think
there are… for every diabetic you find, you‘ll find there‘s a spouse who‘s
carrying part of the load, and coping with a lot of the problems that diabetes
can bring. It‘s difficult, I think, to consider what it would be like being
a diabetic absolutely on one‘s own. I was on my own for over a year, after
my first wife died, and when I say ‘on my own‘, I think the important thing
is that you need to be sharing a house with somebody if you‘re a diabetic
and want to be absolutely sure that you‘re going to be able to cope with anything
that your condition may send you. And I‘m glad that my new wife is perfectly
happy to take it on. I think she‘s found it to be, in some ways, much more
demanding than she thought, but also much less worrying than she thought,
and I think she‘s managing all right. I‘m certainly the best served out of
the whole aspect of it.
|
| | (31)
In what ways do you think your life might have been different if you hadn‘t
been diabetic?
That‘s an interesting question,
isn‘t it? It‘s not one I‘ve ever really thought about very much, perhaps
because of being relatively young when I developed diabetes. I do remember
when my mother was psyching me up to go back to school for the first time
after my diagnosis, I remember asking her a question, to which I think I knew
the answer, but I wanted to confirmation - "is there any possibility
that this is going to come to an end?", and her saying "no, I‘m
afraid I think you‘ll be injecting insulin for the rest of your life".
And I think she found answering that question much harder than I found it
listening to the answer. I think I knew what the answer was, so it wasn‘t
upsetting. She found it really absolutely tore her apart to have to tell
a boy that he was going to have all these things to cope with for the rest
of his life. But, in a very real sense, I accepted it then, and I‘ve had
it ever since. If I hadn‘t been diabetic, there are very few occupations
that I might have wanted to take on that I could have taken on, but can‘t
now. I don‘t think I wanted to be a heavy goods vehicle driver or an airline
pilot, and diabetics have broken ground in a great many areas where I wouldn‘t
have dreamt of trying to take it on anyway. It would have been interesting
to be able to eat sweets whenever I wanted to, but all that would have done...
but I don‘t think it would have done me any good at all, and my teeth would
have suffered. So, it‘s probably just as well.
What message would you have for
someone newly diagnosed with diabetes now?
And possibly for their mum as
well, I guess. I think it‘s possible you may get a view of what the future‘s
going to be like, which can be dreadfully pessimistic, and I‘d want to say
that it doesn‘t have to be as bad as all that. It‘s important to understand
that most of the things people are advising you to do, they‘re advising you
to do for your own benefit, and that therefore you must try to trust most
of the advice you get, if it‘s not inconsistent with other advice. I think
probably I‘d say, don‘t ever get downhearted, and definitely make sure you
do learn how to control it for yourself, and carry on making use of that knowledge
all the time. It‘s not something you can turn off like a tap. You‘re diabetic
twenty four hours a day, and you‘re lucky if you get the chance to forget
that for two hours on end. The advice for a mother is, for Pete‘s sake, don‘t
worry about it too much; it‘s not as bad as all that. There are far, far
more diseases that can affect one‘s life very much more than diabetes must.
Going back to Dr Lawrence, Dr Lawrence was very keen on making sure that all
his patients, and their parents, knew that diabetes wasn‘t the end of a normal
life. It didn‘t mean they were unhealthy. They didn‘t have to carry a portable
set of scales around and weigh everything they ate, and control it down to
the last half ounce. And he was very keen to make sure that his patients
were self-sufficient, and as little of a load as they possibly could be on
those around them. And that, I think, is the objective that all diabetics
would want other newly diagnosed diabetics to meet as well.
|
|
|
|
|
|